How to Fix 21 Common Cooking and Baking Mistakes

Written by Carly Hallman

Ah, how the best-laid plans so often go awry, especially in the kitchen. No matter what recipe you have or how often you’ve made something, you’re bound to make common cooking mistakes like these. But don’t worry; you don’t have to toss out that pan of pasta! These clever food hacks are here to rescue your dinner. So, whether your son’s shouted, “My chili is too spicy!” or your spouse has come in to ask, “Why has my cake cracked on top?,” you’ll be able to help them fix it with very little stress (and save money at the same time)!

How to Fix 21 Common Cooking and Baking Mistakes infographic

Would you like to embed this infographic on your site?

How to Fix 21 Common Cooking and Baking Mistakes

Cooking
Mistake Fixes
Too Salty:
  1. For soup dishes, dilute with water. Add a raw cut potato while cooking to absorb salts.
  2. Add acidity with white wine vinegar or lemon.
  3. Soak uncooked meats that are too salty in water for a 2 hours.
  4. Add a creamy component like avocado, sour cream, or heavy cream, if possible.
Too Spicy:
  1. Add dairy like sour cream, mayo, or plain yogurt.
  2. Add some texture like rice or quinoa.
  3. Add a little sugar.
  4. Stir in a tablespoon of nut butter.
  5. Add more of the non-spicy ingredients included in the recipe.
Too Sweet:
  1. Add lemon or lime juice to balance sugar.
  2. Add fats, such as olive oil or avocado.
  3. Do NOT add salt.
Too Sour:
  1. Add a bit of honey or sugar to dishes with excessive vinegar.
  2. Add chopped carrots to overly-acidic sauces.
Poor Searing:
  1. You may be flipping the meat too soon or too often. It is ready to flip when your spatula slides underneath easily.
  2. Make sure the pan is hot enough before adding meat. Wait for oil to ripple. Medium to medium-high quickly cooks the outside while sealing in moisture.
Food is Soggy or Doesn’t Brown:
  1. Overcrowding a pan prevents steam from escaping and increases moisture. Make sure there is no overlapping.
Deep-Fried Food Too Greasy:
  1. Make sure the frying oil is heated between 325-400 degrees. Hotter oil repels water.
  2. Frying in smaller batches helps maintain hot oil temperature.
Rubbery Hard-Boiled Eggs:
  1. Immediately submerge cooked eggs in cold water to halt the cooking process.
Overcooked or Soggy Pasta:
  1. Heat up oil in large shallow pan and add drained pasta. Use tongs to gently toss and break up stickiness.
  2. Add plenty of salt to the water. This helps prevent sogginess by roughing up the surface.
Baking
Mistake Fixes
Uneven Cake:
  1. Wrap Bake-Even strips around the pan, or make your own – cut a towel into strips, soak in water, and tie around pan.
  2. With a clean paper towel, gently push down on the raised top of a baked cake while still hot.
Cracked Layer Cake:
  1. Cracks in cakes are usually caused by a too hot oven. Check with an oven thermometer.
  2. If top of cake is cracked, carefully slice it off with a serrated bread knife.
  3. If cake is tasty but too crumbly, try making a trifle by layering cake pieces in a deep bowl with whipped cream and fruit.
Dry Cake:
  1. Poke holes in the top and brush with simple sugar syrup.
Not Baking Evenly:
  1. Make sure dough is rolled and distributed evenly.
  2. Check if oven temperature is accurate with an oven thermometer.
  3. Test for hot spots. Toast slices of bread in the middle of the rack and note more toasted areas. Avoid these spots or rotate pans while baking.
Cookies Spread Too Much:
  1. Let butter soften to room temperature for about an hour. Don’t microwave.
  2. Place eggs in warm water for 10 minutes to reach room temperature.
  3. Make sure baking powder and soda are fresh and active.
  4. Chill the dough before baking.
Weird Texture:
  1. Sift flour to air it out for consistent measurements. Level with the flat edge of a knife.
  2. Use the right kind of measuring cup for liquid and dry ingredients.
Egg Whites Won’t Fluff:
  1. Use room temperature eggs.
  2. Use a copper, stainless steel, or glass bowl and dry mixers.
  3. Whip at high speed until stiff peaks form and stay when you lift beater out of the bowl.
Sunken Baked Goods:
  1. Put batter in the oven as soon as it is ready.
  2. Do NOT open the oven door while baking.
  3. Make sure you use the right amount of rising agent.
Too Firm and Chewy:
  1. Avoid overmixing the dough or cranking up the speed of your mixer.
  2. Mix wet ingredients first, then add dry ingredients. This prevents the over development of gluten.
Cookies Harden After Cooling:
  1. Make sure oven temperature is accurate with oven thermometer.
  2. If using a dark cookie sheet, reduce temperature by 25°F.
  3. Grease cookie sheets sparingly, or use parchment paper.
Storage Changed Cookie Consistency:
  1. Always cool cookies completely before storing.
  2. Don’t combine crisp and soft cookies in the same container.
  3. Store in airtight containers.
  4. Store soft cookies with apple wedge to retain moisture.
  5. “Recrisp” crisp cookies by baking at 300°F for five minutes and cool on rack.
  6. Don’t refrigerate cookies unless they have a cream or custard filling.
Melted Chocolate Clumping:
  1. Add a small amount of vegetable oil and stir.

Sources:

When a dash of salt was accidentally a handful (or you confused the sugar jar with the salt pig), there’s a lot of different options for fixing your salty food. Here’s how to fix a recipe that is too salty:

  • “My soup is too salty!” For soup, too salty of a broth can be fixed a variety of ways, the most obvious being to add water. A raw cut potato can help absorb the salt. Adding acidity like vinegar or lemon can cut through it as well.
  • “I made my gravy too salty!” Add more heavy cream and flour, making the gravy more of a roux.
  • “I just poured salt all over my steak!” For meats, try soaking it in water for 2 hours. If that’s not enough, consider adding a squeeze of lemon that might bring up acidity and cut through the salt.

Food Too Spicy To Even Taste

Don’t make grandma cry with your extreme flavors. Add more food to thin out the spiciness with these tricks.

  • “I made chili too spicy!” How to fix it is essentially to just add a ton of non-spicy ingredients: water, sugar, rice, quinoa, or beans. If chili is too spicy add more water or carbohydrates, which can thin it out. But if you don’t want to turn a recipe for three people into a recipe for twenty people, here’s how to cool down chili that is too spicy: add sour cream, mayo, or yogurt. Dairy can cool down your spices quickly. Sugar and nut butter such as peanut butter can coat the palate and shield from spice as well.
  • “I made soup too spicy!” How to fix soup that is too spicy is essentially the same as how to fix chili that is too spicy: add more water or carbohydrates to thin it out, or cool it down with dairy.
  • “I love this curry recipe, but it makes me cry.” For Thai curries, a spoonful of peanut butter can add that umami element while toning everything down. (Make sure no one is allergic, of course.) A spoonful of yogurt matches curry well, too, and you can always cook more rice to go along with your meal.

Food Too Sweet For Anything But Dessert

Oh, no! You’ve swapped the sugar jar and the salt pig again!

  • “I made my spaghetti sauce too sweet!” It might seem like adding salt is a good idea, but it actually is not going to work. You’ll want to add more acid (tomato or lemon juice) or fats (olive oil).

Food That Makes You Pucker Your Lips

Sour foods like olives, pickles, and other foods can drown out umami or sweet flavors really easily. Vinegar is powerful stuff; there’s a reason we can also use it as a cleaning solution.

  • “I made grandma’s tomato sauce too sour!” When you’ve made pasta sauce too sour, the fix is actually pretty easy: add honey or sugar.
  • “I added too much vinegar to my soup or sauce.” Add carrots, which are great for soaking up acids. Water and sugar can also help.

Wacky and Unpleasant Textures

People eat food for flavor, but most people also enjoy texture. It’s the soundtrack to the movie that is your dinner plate. A bad mouthfeel can wreck a meal; here are some cooking hacks to make your food as plump, crunchy, moist, or snappy as it needs to be.

  • “Can you possibly fix overcooked pasta?” Sure, you can give it a try! Put some oil in a pan and gently toss it over low heat. That can sometimes soak up moisture. In the future, you should add more salt to the water.
  • “I made rubbery eggs.” In the future, blanch your eggs by submerging them in cold or icy water to stop the cooking process.
  • “I’ve got no sear on my steak!” Don’t fuss with your meat too much, especially if you’re using a cast iron pan. Let your pan get hot enough before putting it down, and let it sit for a few minutes before you flip.
  • “This fried food is too oily.” Is your oil clean or hot enough? Make sure you are frying in small batches and heating it enough, giving plenty of space. Also, make sure it has a place to drip clean of oil afterward.

Baking Hacks For the Experimental Baker

Lumpy, weird, or odd textures are par for the course with experimental baking. If your parents’ recipes aren’t coming out as they should, here are some easy ways to fix it; however, note that most of this need to be done the second go-around.

  • “My oven is uneven.” There are several strategies on how to bake cake evenly even with a bad oven. Create your own Bake Even strips and wrap it around the pan.
  • “My cheesecake keeps cracking.” The fix is to cover it up with toppings like cherries or raspberries, but how can it be avoided in the first place? When making cheesecake, try filling a baking sheet with water, then put the tight tin of cheesecake in the water. This is referred to as a water bath.
  • “The cake is too dry.” Here’s how to moisten a dry cake: poke holes in it and then brush the top with simple syrup.
  • “This meringue won’t peak!” Ah, meringue problems. When trying to get egg whites to stiffen or fluff, make sure that your eggs are room temperature and that your equipment is dry, whipping at high speeds.
  • “I made a sad sunken soufflé.” That’s very typical. In the future, make sure you have enough baking soda (or rising agent) and don’t check on it by opening the door and interrupting the baking process.
  • “My cookies are too hard, firm, or chewy.” That’s usually a sign of overmixed dough or odd baking times. Buy an internal temperature gauge for your oven.

You might also like...

The Ultimate Road Trip

The Ultimate Road Trip

Take time to get out of dodge. Can be a plane, train or automobile. This series focuses on good old road trips. Some are a couple miles down the road and some are across the country or across the ocean to the most fantastic scenery or landmarks you've ever seen. Included are how to prepare, fun on the road, and preparation along the way.
Planes, Trains and Automobiles

Planes, Trains and Automobiles

Transportation has shaped our society across the broadest possible spectrum from both practical purposes, as a tool for survival, to aesthetics, as a personal expression and style and a millennium worth of history and science from the Orient Express offering transportation in 1883 to the Japanese Bullet train today that travels 200 MPH, vehicles are critical to our existance and at the same time sensationalized in film, as depicted in James Bond films and unusual video game vehicles. Few things we own have as much importance as the vehicles we own or dream to own one day .